Turks & Caicos vs St. Lucia

Trying to decide between Turks & Caicos and St. Lucia?

These are both amazing Caribbean vacations, but they appeal to very different travelers. Turks & Caicos is all about beaches, water, and relaxation. St. Lucia is about scenery, romance, and unforgettable views.

Turks & Caicos Is Better If...

  • You want incredible beaches
  • You care about water color
  • You love snorkeling
  • You want a quieter vacation
  • You want a luxury beach escape

St. Lucia Is Better If...

  • You want romance
  • You want dramatic scenery
  • You are planning a honeymoon
  • You want mountain views
  • You want a destination with a wow factor

Comparison Score

A quick look at how Turks & Caicos and St. Lucia compare.

Beaches
Turks & Caicos: 10/10
St. Lucia: 8/10
Romance
Turks & Caicos: 8/10
St. Lucia: 10/10
Water Color
Turks & Caicos: 10/10
St. Lucia: 8/10
Scenery
Turks & Caicos: 7/10
St. Lucia: 10/10
Snorkeling
Turks & Caicos: 10/10
St. Lucia: 8/10
Honeymoon Feel
Turks & Caicos: 8/10
St. Lucia: 10/10

Best Beaches

Winner: Turks & Caicos

Few destinations can compete with Grace Bay and the water color of Turks & Caicos.

Best Honeymoon

Winner: St. Lucia

The Pitons and dramatic scenery make St. Lucia one of the Caribbean's best honeymoon destinations.

Best Water

Winner: Turks & Caicos

The water is one of the biggest reasons people return to Turks & Caicos again and again.

Most Memorable Views

Winner: St. Lucia

St. Lucia's mountain scenery creates some of the most memorable views in the Caribbean.

Rob's Pick

If I wanted the best beaches, snorkeling, and water in the Caribbean, I would choose Turks & Caicos.

If I wanted romance, scenery, a honeymoon, and a destination that feels truly special, I would choose St. Lucia.

Thinking About Turks & Caicos Or St. Lucia?

Tell me what matters most to you and I'll help narrow down which destination is the better fit.